| 2024 | Fran Acker | Village of Wolcott |
| 2023 | Liz Gaynor | Village of Sands Point |
| 2022 | Susan Walsh | Village of Floral Park |
| 2021 | Amanda Detschner | Village of Barker |
| 2020 | | None Given |
| 2019 | Lori Queor | Village of Potsdam |
| 2018 | Patricia M. Seal | Village of Patchogue |
| 2017 | Robert Juliano | Village of Port Jefferson |
| 2016 | Karen Navin | Village of Laurel Hollow |
| 2015 | Brenda McConnell | Village of Brownville |
| 2014 | Darlene RexfordLori Cashel | Village of AdamsVillage of Adams |
| 2013 | Tamara Bonomo | Village of Camden |
| 2012 | Shirley Sanfilippo | Village of Celoron |
| 2011 | Louis M. DiDomenico | Village of Kings Point |
| 2010 | Joyce M. Jezewski | Village of East Aurora |
| 2009 | Brian S. Ridgway | Village of Garden City |
| 2008 | Kathleen L. Santelli | Village of Great Neck Estates |
| 2007 | Bonnie J. Page | Village of Speculator |
| 2006 | Ms. Margaret "Peggy" Cass | City of Geneva |
| 2005 | Kathie Montigelli | Village of Black River |
| 2004 | Jim Koury | City of Oneonta |
| 2003 | Vikie Strong | Village of Celeron |
| 2002 | Sally Ponce | South Floral Park |
| 2001 | Jill Mattison | Sandy Creek & Lacona |
| 2000 | John Giordano | Farmingdale |
| 1999 | Shawn Cullinane | Lindenhurst |
| 1998 | Leonard Verrastro | Mamaroneck |
| 1997 | Dorothy Aiello | Asharoken |
| 1996 | Richard "Fritz" Falanka | Port Chester |
| 1995 | Charles L. Michaux, III | Buffalo |
| 1994 | Theresa L. Cummins | Williamsville |
| 1993 | Kimberly LaMarche | Hammondsport |
| 1992 | Raymond J. Carlo | Akron |
| 1991 | Katherine Adams | Altamont |
| 1990 | George Koerner | Holland Patent |
| 1989 | Gerald DePasquale | Lackawanna |
| 1988 | Joan Schoen Freehan | Sag Harbor |
| 1987 | Gail Riggs | Springville |
| 1986 | Ruth Cobb | Oakfield |
